The Perfect Storm: How PJM's Record-Breaking Capacity Auction Results Signal a New Era of Energy Costs

The energy landscape has fundamentally shifted, and businesses across the Midwest are about to feel the impact in their bottom lines. The recent PJM Base Residual Auction (BRA) results for the 2026/2027 and 2027/2028 delivery years have sent shockwaves through the industry, with capacity prices reaching unprecedented levels that will translate directly into higher electricity costs which started June 2025.

A Market Under Stress

We've entered a period of significant market tightening that wasn't accidental. The numbers tell a stark story of supply and demand fundamentally out of balance.

Over the past year alone, forecasted demand has surged by 5 gigawatts—a massive increase that reflects the new reality of our energy-hungry economy. Meanwhile, the supply side has consistently underperformed expectations. New renewable resources haven't come online as quickly as anticipated, and delayed retirements of existing facilities have failed to provide the expected capacity buffer. The result? A market that was simply short on available power.

The most recent auction cleared at the price cap of $329.17 per megawatt-day. Perhaps more telling is what the data has revealed: without that cap in place, prices would have soared even higher—over $388 per megawatt-day. This isn't just a minor market adjustment; it's a fundamental shift that signals how stressed our energy infrastructure has become.

The Driving Forces Behind Unprecedented Price Increases

The astronomical 9X increase in capacity prices—from $2.2 billion to $14.7 billion—didn't occur in a vacuum. Three critical factors have converged to create this perfect storm of energy cost escalation.

The AI and Data Center Explosion

The most significant driver of increased energy demand comes from an unexpected source: artificial intelligence. The proliferation of AI large language models and the data centers that support them has created an unprecedented surge in electricity consumption. These facilities process staggering amounts of data, requiring massive amounts of power to train AI systems on publicly available information. Meta's recent announcement of an $800 million data center in Northwest Ohio is just one example of the infrastructure investments driving this demand surge.

Each new data center announcement adds strain to an already stretched grid, and this trend shows no signs of slowing. Industry experts predict this increased demand will continue for the next 3 to 5 years as more AI facilities and traditional data centers come online.

Natural Gas: A Complex Mix of Geopolitical Uncertainties, Weather and Inventory Challenges

Geopolitical Uncertainties

The ongoing war in Ukraine continues to impact global energy markets in complex ways. Russian sanctions have made exporting gas more attractive to U.S. producers, who have been enjoying premium pricing for exports to Europe. If these sanctions are eased, producers will be less incentivized to maintain high production levels, potentially affecting domestic storage levels and making it more challenging to refill inventories.

Weather and Inventory Challenges

Weather has always played a role in natural gas markets, but retirements of coal facilities force the added strain of increased demand. With natural gas making up roughly 43% of the fuel mix used in electricity generation, serving the AI and data center explosion, summer AC load, winter heat load, the need to fill storage and increased exports are depleting natural gas inventories more than in recent memory. Since electricity prices are highly correlated to natural gas pricing, this sets a higher bar for refilling inventories during the "injection" season from April through October. Adding to the pressure of meeting storage; Any disruption—from hurricanes to pipeline issues—could mean less of a cushion for next winter, creating additional upward pressure on energy prices.

State Response and Market Evolution

The dramatic auction results have prompted PJM member states to explore alternative approaches to capacity planning. Many states now firmly believe that the current capacity auction model isn't producing sufficient and timely incentives for the market to bring new capacity online when needed.

As a result, several states are beginning to review "self-build" options for new gas-fired generation. This represents a significant shift in thinking about how to ensure grid reliability while managing costs—a recognition that the market-driven approach may need supplementation with more direct state intervention.

The 2027/2028 auction results, which cleared at essentially the same price cap negotiated by Pennsylvania's Governor, underscore how political considerations are increasingly influencing what were once purely market-driven outcomes.

The Window of Opportunity

While utility prices are set to skyrocket, there's a silver lining for savvy businesses: wholesale forward electricity markets remain relatively favorable compared to the impending utility rate increases. Energy traders are still trying to determine how to position themselves in this volatile environment, creating a brief window where forward contracts can be secured at rates significantly below what utility pricing will become.

This disconnect between wholesale and utility pricing won't last forever. As the reality of capacity cost increases works through the system, wholesale markets will inevitably adjust upward. The question isn't whether prices will rise—it's how quickly businesses can act to insulate themselves from these increases.

Strategic Recommendations for Businesses

Given this unprecedented market environment, energy experts recommend that businesses take immediate action to protect themselves from the coming price surge. The most effective strategy involves securing fixed pricing for 100% of consumption needs through at least 2027, effectively eliminating price exposure during this period of extreme volatility.

Beyond basic price protection, sophisticated energy management strategies can help offset some of these cost increases:

• Demand Response Programs: Can provide revenue streams that help offset higher capacity costs.

• Capacity Tag Optimization: Properly managing when and how much power you use during peak periods can minimize capacity charges.

• Customized Energy Strategies: A comprehensive approach that considers your specific usage patterns, facility characteristics, and business operations.

The most successful businesses will be those that move quickly to implement comprehensive energy management strategies rather than simply accepting whatever rates their utility imposes.

Looking Ahead

The energy market has entered a new era characterized by unprecedented demand growth, supply constraints, and regulatory uncertainty. The days of stable, predictable energy costs are likely behind us for the foreseeable future. Businesses that recognize this shift and take proactive steps to manage their energy exposure will be best positioned to thrive in this new environment.

The PJM auction results serve as a wake-up call for the entire Midwest business community. With capacity costs increasing ninefold and this trend expected to continue for years, the time for action is now. The window for securing favorable rates is closing, and businesses that delay risk facing the full impact of these historic price increases.

---

About TogetherSolve

TogetherSolve is a leading energy consulting firm that specializes in helping businesses navigate complex energy markets and reduce costs through strategic energy management. Our team of experts provides comprehensive energy solutions including rate negotiations, demand response programs, capacity optimization, and customized energy strategies. We work with businesses across various industries to deliver measurable savings—typically 20-40% on energy costs—through our proven expertise in wholesale energy markets, regulatory compliance, and innovative cost management techniques. Our services are provided at no cost to clients, as we're compensated through partnerships with energy suppliers, ensuring our interests are aligned with achieving maximum savings for the businesses we serve.